Secondary Curriculum & Instruction
  • Tools, Tips, & Tricks
  • Remote Learning at RPS
  • Resources
  • Grading For Learning
  • Links We Love
  • Meet the Team
  • Get Social
  • K-12 RPS C&I Links
    • Elementary C&I Online
    • RPS C&I Webpage
    • MN Dept. of Ed. Standards
    • RPS Prioritized Learnings >
      • Background & Process
      • Middle School Prioritized Learnings
      • High School Prioritized Learnings
      • Proficiency Scales
      • Continuing the Process
    • RPS Independent Study PD Request Form
  • Suggest a Blog Topic

Tools, Tips, & Tricks

Motivation: Moving Beyond Carrots and Sticks

3/18/2019

 
Lately, I have been thinking about my own education and how I, as a student, have changed over time.  In my K-12 education, I was a successful student who was “good at school.”  I did what the teachers and adults asked, I followed their examples of how to solve problems (I could follow any procedure in math when I knew the formula and worked through a few with the teacher), I followed their rules (no running, no swearing, etc.), and was always considered a “good kid.”  Once I went to college to get my undergrad and later my master’s degree, I realized I wasn’t as "good at school" as I had once thought. 
 
When I look back at why this shift occurred, I realize it was because as a K-12 student I wasn’t as interested in the learning and understanding of what I did, as I was with getting good grades (I was a passive learner), having teachers and classmates like me (the 'relator' in me) and being labeled as a "good student" and friend.  Now, don’t get me wrong: I did learn a lot during my K-12 years of education and I had a lot of great teachers, I just didn’t always strive to know or better understand the “why” behind what I was learning. I simply wasn’t motivated to do so.
Image of a carrot and a stick
As an adult learner and as an educator, I realize that none of my former teachers were trying to make me a passive learner, I just wasn’t motivated to be as active in my learning as I could have been.

I believe that as educators we want our students to do well in school but also be motivated and active in their learning. What follows are some things to consider as we try to motivate our students to become active learners rather than passive learners, moving them beyond traditional carrot and stick motivators.

|    1    |
Adjusting for 21st-Century Learners

Image of a brain fill of gears turning
A colleague introduced to the book Drive by Daniel Pink. The first two chapters really hit me: they highlighted what we are doing in education now,  noted what we can change, and identified why it is important that we do. Both chapters hit directly upon motivation.  The chapters “The Rise and Fall of Motivation 2.0” and “Seven Reasons Carrots and Sticks (Often) Don’t Work. . .” tie into what we see in our classrooms every day, even though his book is spun more for the business-world.  If you haven’t read this book, I highly recommend  you do! 

If you want a quick idea of what Pink is talks about in Drive, then watching his TED Talk: “The Puzzle of Motivation” is a great starting point:

My favorite part of this talk is when he mentions that what motivated 20th-century learners (me) doesn’t often motivate 21st-century learners (our students).

|    2    |
The Impact Homework (Doesn't) Have

Image of worried student doing homework
Looking at ways to motivate students in the classroom and comparing it to what has been done in education for years, John Hattie explores the effect size of these different actions, noting if they have a positive, negative, or neutral effect  on our students.  As secondary teachers who we all likely taught in a system that was incentive driven, we need to start taking a closer look at what we are doing to motivate our students and to help them be active, life-long learners.

One of the things teachers tend to struggle with is the homework we give and the reason we give it.  According to Hattie, homework has an effect size of .29 (very low).  We have had students who could do the homework and were motivated to get them all right (i.e. get a good grade) but then struggled when asked to explain why certain rules/procedures worked and why it didn’t. When asked to solve a problem another way, students usually groan and ask, "Why?". We have also had students who did the homework but didn’t really understand the material, as well as students who just didn’t do the homework at all. So clearly, just assigning homework was not a motivator for most students in class and tying it to grades make it even worse.  

|    3    |
Three Key Motivational Elements: Autonomy, Mastery, & Purpose

Image of autonomy, mastery, and purpose working in harmony
Continuing to look at what we can do to help motivate students, implementing a different mindset, specifically growth mindset, into how our classrooms operate is huge. We need to model and encourage making mistakes and focusing on what can be learned from those mistakes.  Instead of modeling how to solve problems, we need to give out students the problems first and see what they can figure out on their own.  We should incorporate more projects that are real-life based (the why of what we are doing is relevant), give students timely feedback versus grades (a .75 effect size from Hattie), and have students self-report on what they learned and what grade they earned (a whopping 1.44 effect size from Hattie!) should become the norm.

Making our classes relevant, interesting, and challenging to our students will help with their motivation.  As Daniel Pink refers in his book Drive, if we make tasks in our classrooms fit into one or more of the three key categories--Autonomy, Mastery, or Purpose--our students will move from being compliant (grade driven) to engaged (seeing the value).


​I know from my own experience that when I switched from being all about grades and more about the why and how, what I was learning became important. I became a totally different student. I also remember far more about what I was doing rather than just knowing I had learned it once upon a time.  I know it isn’t always an easy transition: when we find things that work and that we are comfortable with, change can be hard.  But, in knowing our students face different opportunities than we may have faced, it's time to try things a little differently.
This post brought to you by Jen Coenen, Secondary Implementation Associate and STEM Village Director

Comments are closed.
    Suggest a topic for the blog

    Enjoy our Blog!

    Members of the Secondary C&I team weekly post useful tools, tips, and tricks to help you help students. 

    Categories

    All
    Analysis & Inquiry
    Behavior Mgmt
    Career Pathways
    Community Partnerships
    Community Schools
    Content Understanding
    Co Teaching
    Co-teaching
    Cultural Relevancy
    Curriculum
    EL Learners
    Grading For Learning
    Homelessness
    Instructional Dialogue
    Instructional Learning Formats
    Mental Health
    Planning For A Sub
    Positive Climate
    Prioritized Learnings
    Productivity
    Professional Dev.
    Quality Of Feedback
    Regard For S's Perspective
    Special Education
    Student Engagement
    Teacher Sensitivity
    Technology

    Archives

    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016

    RSS Feed

    Get Social with Us
    Visit the District Site for Curriculum & Instruction

​We would love to help you help your students!
  • Tools, Tips, & Tricks
  • Remote Learning at RPS
  • Resources
  • Grading For Learning
  • Links We Love
  • Meet the Team
  • Get Social
  • K-12 RPS C&I Links
    • Elementary C&I Online
    • RPS C&I Webpage
    • MN Dept. of Ed. Standards
    • RPS Prioritized Learnings >
      • Background & Process
      • Middle School Prioritized Learnings
      • High School Prioritized Learnings
      • Proficiency Scales
      • Continuing the Process
    • RPS Independent Study PD Request Form
  • Suggest a Blog Topic